When you’re cycling, a small and cheap cycling computer is typically all you need to display your most important data such as speed, pace, distance, and time. However, most modern smartphones are also capable of giving you this information with a little bit of third-party help. So, which one should you ultimately choose? Should you save a little money and use your smartphone as a cycling computer or should you opt for the smaller, more user-friendly and aerodynamic cycling computer?
The debate on cycling computers vs smartphones has been going around ever since smartphones got advanced enough to track your cycling sessions. While there isn’t any definitive answer to it, we can easily compare both devices in terms of their features and see which one will come on top and most importantly – which will fit your needs better.
If you’re looking for a third alternative, I suggest checking out my detailed guide on the best fitness trackers for cycling. There, I’ve listed the top models for this year as well as the numerous features that you need to take into account when buying one.
Table of Contents
Features To Compare
When it comes to comparing the two devices, we must take a detailed approach and size them up based on all their common features. Only that way we will be able to objectively determine which one is best for you and draw our conclusions at the end of the article. Here are all the features that we will be comparing:
- Dimensions
- Durability
- Display
- Performance
- Battery Life
- Tracking Accuracy & Reliability
- Weatherproofing
- Aerodynamics
- Price
- Other features and accessories
Dimensions
In terms of the dimensions, cycling computers have a clear-cut advantage. While there are some compact smartphones, they are still nowhere near the size of the average cycling speedometer. That is, in fact, one of the main disadvantages of the smartphone – it is just too big. This creates a whole range of issues for people that want to use their smartphones. The size will also affect other features which we will discuss in a moment, one of the most important ones being aerodynamics.
Durability
The durability of both of these devices greatly depends on their price. Obviously, the more expensive a smartphone is, the more durable it will be. Still, smartphones are typically made out of glass these days and glass is glass and glass breaks. It is only fair to compare them in terms of their durability only if you worry about accidentally drop one of them. Since bike computers will rarely be picked out of their holder on your bike’s front bar, there isn’t much of a concern about their durability. Smartphones, on the other hand, might get picked up, especially if you stop and pick up a call or want to type in something with both your hands.
Display
Bike speedometers typically have small displays while modern smartphones all have 5-inch displays or bigger. On top of that, smartphones have colored displays which offer a ton more real estate for various functions and graphs. Still, if you’re only getting a speedometer for its basic functionality, its LCD display will be clearly visible in most cases. That isn’t even taking into consideration that there are some cycling computers which are quite large and have night-time modes to illuminate the display. Smartphones don’t have to worry about cycling in the dark as they are all backlit and the ones with LED displays have the option to turn all their unused pixels off, leaving you with the illuminated numbers only.
To learn how speedometers work and what other features they can have, make sure you head over my guide on the best bike speedometers. Now, let’s compare these devices’ performance…
Performance
The performance is where it’s all at. Bike computers have the advance of being super fast and really reliable. Part of that is due to their simple nature and external sensors that they rely on. In other words, it isn’t hard to put out a great performance if the device is tracking only a few metrics. The more expensive both devices get, the more complicated their functions will get and this is where smartphones take a slight edge. While premium bike computers have decent performance and good usability, smartphones are just built for that and will give you a lot more to work with on an already optimized software such as Android or iOS.
Furthermore, there are countless of good cycling apps for mobile phones with each of them having a myriad of functions and features to help you track your cycling session. Bike computers, on the other hand, are limited by their software and to get a top-shelf performance you will need to pay a big chunk of money which works in favor of smartphones even more.



